My [husband, daughter, mom, etc.] is the [insert superlative adjective here, e.g. best, prettiest, smartest] EVER.
I know I'm going to sound hypersensitive, but I find this SO OFFENSIVE. Seriously. When using a superlative, you are by definition making a comparison. For non-grammarian readers, a superlative is basically a descriptive word with an -est at the end of the word. It's usually fine when using it to describe inanimate objects or ideas, but it's pretty much never fine when used about people in public.* For example, when someone tells me they have the best husband ever, I know they don't intend to say that my husband is worse by comparison, but that is exactly what they are saying. My mental reaction is usually, Hmm, I think mine's pretty swell, thank you very much.
Granted, I used to use this phrase all the time to describe people, that is until I bore the brunt of this comparison enough times that it became very hurtful to me. People don't intend it, but after awhile, especially to people whose Love Language is Words of Affirmation, it's very difficult to indirectly be told you, someone you love, or something you've done is second best. As a Christian, I think I can without question say that edifying one person while demeaning another is not really what God intends. I mean it's pretty explicit in Ephesians 4:29, no matter which version you read. The New Living Translation is not usually my go-to version, but I'm a fan of it with this verse: "Don't use foul or abusive language. Let everything you say be good and helpful, so that your words will be an encouragement to those who hear them."
I am in no way an expert on this. I am also in no way inferring that we should walk on eggshells around people, always worrying that we might offend others. That's just plain nonsense. But think about it, would you walk into a room full of teachers and loudly proclaim to one of them, You're the best teacher EVER!!!? No, you wouldn't. Or if you did, you'd probably get a lot of scowls. Nobody wants to be second best. Now if I told you that Dr. Pepper is the best carbonated beverage EVER, I'd be right. It absolutely is. :o) And if you told me that The Office is the funniest show EVER, I'd probably tell you that you were crazy. I don't think I'll ever understand the draw of that show. But no one would be hurt. I think the Queen of Long-Winded made her point.
I just had to get that out. A huge percentage of people I know use this phrase. I think even my husband recently used it to describe me on Facebook the other day. So I want to clarify that I am not directing this at anyone in particular and don't want anyone to feel judged by me. I just think that we too easily say things we think without considering their effect on others, and I felt the need to present people with a viewpoint on a topic about which they probably haven't given much thought. People are obviously free to formulate their own opinions.
_____________________________________________________
*I totally tell my husband that he is the best ever in private but never within earshot of other people. When other people are around, I love to publicly encourage him but try to do so without superlatives.
Thanks for clearly expressing your thoughts on this, Laura. I've never thought about the affect superlatives can have on others. I want to be more mindful of this.
ReplyDeleteI've been wanting to write this post for several months, but it took me awhile to process what exactly was the cause. I finally discovered a few weeks ago that it was this. I'm definitely a Words person, so it definitely was having an emotional effect on me. I am still working on it myself. Thank you for your willingness to be sensitive to this.
ReplyDeleteI seriously was thinking the whole time, "Jeez, I make joking comments like this all the time. Wait a minute, is this about me? No, she clears that up towards the end…had me scared there for a min. This is a good post, it's so true too. Hrm...?" Anyways, I like your opinions in this blog.
ReplyDeleteHumm hi there. First time visitor :::waves::: I see your point here, however I really don't understand why you're so bent out of shape about something quite silly. When you say "As a Christian, I think I can without question say that edifying one person while demeaning another is not really what God intends." I get it, however you're implying that the person saying it is INTENDING to be offensive and imply that yes indeed, her husband IS way better than yours (just going off your example). I think you're taking it out of context and surely being way to sensitive about the subject. I never even cared to notice if I or anyone else said this. In fact, if I saw one of my girlfriends' husbands being super awesome and she said "OMG my husband is the BEST!" I would surely think so! Because I know she is not comparing him to my husband who is also THE BEST. It's all about perspective. I think that you and anyone else out there who agrees with you are taking it way to personally. Feeling that kind of joy about the one you love and sharing it with the world IS what God wants us to do. SHARE THE LOVE! :)
ReplyDeleteSorry if this came off harsh...just my opinion on your opinions. I'd be interested in reading more of your posts, whether we agree with each other or not. Clearly, my blog is the BEST (okay I'll stop! j/k lol) Seriously though, I will be reading more. :)
Sarah, thank you for visiting my blog and for sharing your views on this. I tend to get passionate about things and in doing so, probably over-emphasize my emotions. SO OFFENSIVE is a little drastic. It's probably a little more accurate to say it annoys me, but not enough to mention it to people in passing conversation yet obviously enough to write my thoughts out on my blog. I do see your point, but I've been thinking this through for months, not to the point of dwelling and obsessing over it, but to process it. I do want to hear people telling me how wonderful their husbands (or whomever) are. I absolutely love that. I think that is really important, especially within earshot of their husbands. And what girl doesn't love her husband bragging on her to his friends?!?
ReplyDeleteI just get hung up on the actual meaning of words people use. The sentence directly before the one you mentioned said, "People don't intend it, but after awhile, especially to people whose Love Language is Words of Affirmation, it's very difficult to indirectly be told you, someone you love, or something you've done is second best." I know it sounds very silly if you aren't sensitive to it. Everyone has different personalities and perspectives on topics, and I'm not trying to change the world or anyone's mind with my blog. It's okay if you disagree. Just my thoughts. :o)
Honey, I think I hear you saying that it is encouraging if you hear someone say something like, "My husband did a very thoughtful thing for me when he..." But to relate the same thought to the same person with different words like, "My husband is the most thoughtful husband ever!" would be offensive because of the unnecessary comparison to get the same point across. Am I understanding you correctly?
ReplyDeleteMom, you've understood me exactly. The former would cause me to smile and say, "Awh, that's so sweet!" The latter causes me to scowl and try not to be offended, entirely missing what the person intended to say because of their poorly chosen words. :o)
ReplyDelete